Best Waterfront Restaurants in Sarasota

As a Sarasota real estate expert, I'm often asked about the best places to enjoy our beautiful coastal scenery. One of my favorite recommendations is to experience our city's stunning waterfront restaurants. Hi, I'm Melissa Loveton, and today I'm excited to share with you my guide to the best waterfront dining options in Sarasota. From casual beachside eateries to upscale establishments, our area offers a diverse array of restaurants where you can savor delicious food while taking in breathtaking views of the Gulf of Mexico and Sarasota Bay.

The Allure of Waterfront Dining in Sarasota

Sarasota's unique geography, with its pristine beaches, barrier islands, and expansive bay, creates the perfect backdrop for unforgettable dining experiences. Whether you're a longtime resident or a visitor, there's something magical about enjoying a meal while watching the sun dip below the horizon or boats gently cruising by. Our waterfront restaurants not only offer fantastic views but also showcase the fresh seafood and local flavors that make Florida's Gulf Coast a culinary destination.

Casual Dining Experiences

Old Florida Charm: Old Salty Dog and Pop's Sunset Grill

For those seeking a laid-back atmosphere with a touch of Old Florida charm, look no further than the Old Salty Dog and Pop's Sunset Grill. The Old Salty Dog, located on City Island, offers a casual dining experience with stunning views of New Pass. Their famous beer-battered hot dogs and fresh seafood make it a local favorite. Don't miss their conch fritters or the chance to spot dolphins playing in the water!

Pop's Sunset Grill in Nokomis is another gem that captures the essence of casual Florida dining. With its massive tiki hut and beautiful views of the Intracoastal Waterway, it's the perfect spot to enjoy a cold drink and watch the sunset. Their menu features everything from fried seafood baskets to refreshing fish tacos.

Tiki Bar Vibes

If you're in the mood for a tropical escape without leaving Sarasota, head to O'Leary's Tiki Bar and Grill. Located in Bayfront Park, this waterfront tiki bar offers a relaxed atmosphere with beautiful views of Sarasota Bay. Enjoy live music, cold drinks, and casual fare like burgers and fish sandwiches while soaking in the Florida sunshine.

Family-Friendly Spots on Anna Maria Island

A short drive north will take you to the charming Anna Maria Island, home to several family-friendly waterfront restaurants. For a more casual option, try the Rod & Reel Pier Restaurant, where you can dine over the water and even try your hand at fishing off the pier.

Upscale Restaurants on the Water in Sarasota

Fine Dining with a View: Marina Jack and Jack Dusty at The Ritz-Carlton

For those special occasions or when you're in the mood for a more upscale dining experience, Sarasota offers some truly exceptional options. Marina Jack, located in downtown Sarasota, provides stunning views of the marina and Sarasota Bay. With both indoor and outdoor seating options, you can enjoy their extensive menu featuring fresh seafood, steaks, and an impressive wine list.

Jack Dusty, situated within The Ritz-Carlton Sarasota, offers a sophisticated dining experience with a modern coastal cuisine menu. Their waterfront location provides beautiful bay views, and the creative cocktails and fresh oyster selection make it a perfect spot for a romantic evening or a celebratory dinner.

Romantic Sunset Dining Experiences

For a romantic evening, consider Ophelia's on the Bay in Siesta Key. This fine dining establishment offers intimate waterfront seating and a menu that changes daily to showcase the freshest ingredients. The panoramic views of Little Sarasota Bay create a magical setting as the sun sets.

Seafood and Steak: The Best of Land and Sea

Many of Sarasota's waterfront restaurants excel in offering both exceptional seafood and perfectly prepared steaks. The Dry Dock Waterfront Grill on Longboat Key is renowned for its grouper preparations and also serves excellent steaks for those preferring turf over surf. With its location right on the water, you can even arrive by boat!

Sarasota Bay and Longboat Key Dining

Dry Dock Waterfront Grill: A Local Favorite

Speaking of Dry Dock Waterfront Grill, this Longboat Key staple deserves special mention. Known for its fresh seafood and spectacular views of Sarasota Bay, it's a favorite among locals and visitors alike. Their herb-crusted grouper is a must-try, and the outdoor seating area provides a perfect vantage point for watching boats go by.

Restaurants with Stunning Sarasota Bay Views

Chart House on Longboat Key offers panoramic views of Sarasota Bay alongside its menu of seafood and steaks. For a unique experience, consider taking a dinner cruise with Marina Jack, which allows you to dine while touring the bay and enjoying the sunset.

New Pass Grill and Bait Shop: A Historic Waterfront Spot

For a taste of local history, visit the New Pass Grill and Bait Shop. This tiny establishment has been serving up burgers, hot dogs, and simple seafood dishes since the 1920s. The view of New Pass and the chance to watch fishermen try their luck make it a charming spot for a casual meal.

Fresh Seafood Specialties on the Water

Oyster Bars and Raw Seafood Offerings

Sarasota's waterfront restaurants are the perfect place to indulge in fresh, raw seafood. The oyster bar at Jack Dusty offers a variety of east and west coast oysters, while Owen's Fish Camp in downtown Sarasota, though not directly on the water, is worth mentioning for its outstanding raw bar and Old Florida atmosphere.

Lobster and Lobster Roll Hotspots

While Florida stone crab might be more iconic, several Sarasota restaurants serve excellent lobster dishes. Marina Jack offers a delicious lobster tail, and for a more casual option, check out New England-style lobster rolls at Owen's Fish Camp or The Old Salty Dog.

Fish Tacos and Other Casual Seafood Delights

For those craving something more casual, many waterfront spots offer excellent fish tacos and other handheld seafood options. Phillippi Creek Oyster Bar, situated on a creek leading to the bay, serves up delicious fish tacos alongside a variety of other seafood dishes in a laid-back waterfront setting.

Bradenton and Anna Maria Island Waterfront Options

Best Waterfront Restaurants in Bradenton

Venturing slightly north to Bradenton opens up even more waterfront dining possibilities. The Beach House Restaurant on Anna Maria Island offers Gulf-front dining with a menu focusing on fresh, locally-sourced ingredients. In Bradenton proper, Pier 22 provides upscale dining with beautiful views of the Manatee River.

Anna Maria Island's Laid-Back Dining Scene

Anna Maria Island is known for its relaxed, Old Florida vibe, and its restaurants reflect this atmosphere. The Waterfront Restaurant offers a mix of fresh seafood and international flavors with a view of Tampa Bay. For a truly casual experience, stop by Rod & Reel Pier for simple seafood dishes served over the water.

Waterfront Happy Hour and Live Music Venues

Many waterfront restaurants in the area offer fantastic happy hour specials and live music. The Kokonut Hut on Bradenton Beach features live music and drink specials with a great view of the Gulf. Back in Sarasota, O'Leary's Tiki Bar and Grill often has live music in the evenings, perfect for enjoying with a cocktail as the sun sets.

Unique Waterfront Dining Experiences in Sarasota County

Nokomis and Casey Key Must Try Spots

Venture south to Nokomis and Casey Key for some hidden waterfront dining gems. Casey Key Fish House offers a true Florida fish house experience with a beautiful view of the Intracoastal Waterway. In Nokomis, Pop's Sunset Grill provides a casual dining experience with stunning sunset views.

Ophelia's on the Bay: Fine Dining on Little Sarasota Bay

Ophelia's on the Bay, mentioned earlier for its romantic setting, deserves another nod for its unique location. Situated on Little Sarasota Bay, it offers a more secluded and intimate waterfront dining experience. The ever-changing menu showcases local seafood and produce, prepared with a creative flair.

Star Fish Company: Fresh Catch in a Fishing Village Setting

For an authentic Florida fishing village experience, make the trip to Star Fish Company in Cortez. This casual market and restaurant serves some of the freshest seafood around, often caught the same day. Enjoy your meal at picnic tables overlooking Sarasota Bay, surrounded by working fishing boats.

Tips for Enjoying Waterfront Dining in Sarasota

Best Times to Visit for Optimal Water Views and Sunsets

To make the most of your waterfront dining experience, try to time your visit with the sunset. In summer, this is usually around 8 PM, while in winter, it can be as early as 5:30 PM. Lunch is also a great time to enjoy water views, with the vibrant blues of the Gulf and Bay on full display.

Reservation Recommendations for Popular Spots

Many of the more upscale restaurants, like Marina Jack and Ophelia's on the Bay, accept reservations. It's wise to book in advance, especially for sunset dining or during peak tourist season (typically winter and early spring).

Seasonal Considerations and Local Events

Keep in mind that Sarasota hosts various events throughout the year that can affect restaurant availability. The Sarasota Film Festival in April and the Suncoast Food & Wine Fest in November are particularly busy times. Hurricane season (June to November) rarely affects dining, but it's always good to have a backup plan.

Beyond Restaurants: Waterfront Bars and Casual Eateries

Bayfront Park and Marina Options

Bayfront Park in downtown Sarasota offers several casual dining options with great views. O'Leary's Tiki Bar and Grill, mentioned earlier, is a standout. Marina Jack's outdoor patio bar is another excellent spot for a casual drink and bite with a view.

Dockside Dining and Boat-Up Restaurants

Many waterfront restaurants in Sarasota offer dockside dining or even allow you to boat up. The Old Salty Dog on City Island and Dry Dock Waterfront Grill both have docks where you can tie up your boat and come in for a meal.

Beach Bars and Casual Waterfront Atmospheres

For a true toes-in-the-sand experience, check out the Siesta Key Beach Pavilion. While not a full-service restaurant, it offers the chance to enjoy a casual meal or snack right on the beach.

A Diverse Waterfront Dining Experience

Sarasota's waterfront dining scene offers something for everyone, from casual beach bars to fine dining establishments. As a local real estate expert, I can attest that our beautiful water views and fresh, local cuisine are just part of what makes Sarasota such a special place to live and visit.

I encourage you to explore these waterfront dining options and discover your own favorites. Whether you're celebrating a special occasion, enjoying a family outing, or simply soaking in another beautiful Sarasota day, our waterfront restaurants provide the perfect backdrop for creating lasting memories.

Remember, the joy of waterfront dining in Sarasota isn't just about the food – it's about the entire experience. The fresh sea air, the sound of lapping waves, and the spectacular views all combine to make dining out an unforgettable adventure. So why not make your next meal a waterfront one? Your taste buds – and your Instagram feed – will thank you!

If you are considering making a move to Sarasota, FL contact us today and we'll help guide you to your perfect home!